WIBTA for giving a bully a 1-star review?

Image credit: Pixabay (This is example image – Not the actual photo)

High School Bullies and Adult Consequences

After discovering that a former high school bully has opened a private therapy practice, a woman grapples with the idea of leaving an honest review based on their tumultuous past. This situation raises questions about accountability and the impact of past actions on present careers. Many can relate to the complexities of navigating relationships with former bullies, especially when their new roles seem at odds with their past behavior. Should honesty prevail, or is it better to let bygones be bygones?

Conflict Over a High School Bully’s Therapy Practice

A 33-year-old woman recently discovered that one of her high school bullies has opened a private therapy practice. This revelation has sparked a dilemma regarding whether to leave a review based on her past experiences. Here’s a breakdown of the situation:

Background: The woman attended high school with the business owner, who was known for her bullying behavior. The experience was described as akin to a “Mean Girls” scenario, leaving lasting negative impressions.
Current Situation: Upon learning about the bully’s new profession, the woman feels conflicted. She is surprised that someone who exhibited such unkind behavior in school is now in a position to provide therapy.
Review Consideration: The woman is contemplating leaving a review for the therapy practice. She believes that honesty is important, especially considering the number of positive reviews from the bully’s friends, which may not reflect the true nature of her character.

The woman is grappling with the implications of her potential review. Here are some key points she is considering:

Impact on Others: She worries that her review could influence others’ decisions about seeking therapy from someone she perceives as untrustworthy.
Personal Feelings: The emotional weight of her past experiences with the bully complicates her judgment. She feels a sense of responsibility to protect others from a negative experience.
Family Drama: The situation has also stirred up family discussions, as relatives have differing opinions on whether she should voice her concerns publicly.
Conflict Resolution: The woman is seeking a way to resolve her internal conflict. She wants to balance her feelings about the past with the potential consequences of her actions.

Ultimately, the woman is left to decide whether to share her honest opinion in a review or to remain silent, weighing the potential fallout against her moral obligation to inform others. This situation highlights the complexities of personal history and professional integrity, especially in the context of family drama and wedding tension that may arise from differing viewpoints on the matter.

This is Original story from Reddit

Image credit: Pixabay (This is example image – Not the actual photo)

Story

I 33F just learned one of my high school bullies has opened a private therapy practice. WIBTA for reviewing it?

“I attended high school with this business owner and am shocked to learn her profession given the Mean Girls experience it was to be her classmate. I would never recommend anyone I care about engage in her practice.”

Considering the amount of reviews from her friends, I figured one ought to be honest.

View the Original Reddit Post Here

Summary of Reddit Comments

The top Reddit comments indicate a strong consensus that the original poster (OP) would be the asshole (YWBTA) for seeking revenge on their former bully. Many users emphasize the importance of personal growth and the need to let go of past grievances, suggesting that holding onto anger can hinder one’s own peace and healing. The comments highlight that while the OP’s feelings are valid, pursuing revenge is not a constructive path and may indicate a need for therapy.

Verdict: YTA

Expert Advice for Resolving the Conflict

It’s understandable to feel conflicted when faced with the actions of someone who has caused you pain in the past. Here are some practical steps to help you navigate this situation while considering both your feelings and the potential impact on others.

Steps for the Original Poster (OP)

Reflect on Your Feelings: Take some time to process your emotions regarding your past experiences with the bully. Journaling or talking to a trusted friend can help clarify your feelings and motivations.
Consider the Bigger Picture: Think about the potential consequences of leaving a review. While your feelings are valid, consider how your actions might affect the bully’s current clients and their therapeutic journey.
Seek Professional Guidance: If you feel overwhelmed, consider speaking with a therapist yourself. They can provide support and help you work through your feelings about the past and the current situation.
Explore Alternative Actions: Instead of leaving a public review, consider reaching out to the bully directly (if you feel safe doing so) to express your feelings. This could lead to a constructive conversation and may help you find closure.
Focus on Your Healing: Prioritize your own healing and well-being. Engaging in activities that promote self-care and personal growth can help you move forward without being weighed down by past grievances.

Steps for Family and Friends

Listen and Validate: If you are a family member or friend, listen to the OP’s feelings without judgment. Validate their experiences and emotions, as this can help them feel supported.
Encourage Constructive Dialogue: Suggest that the OP discuss their feelings with a therapist or counselor. This can provide them with tools to cope with their emotions and make informed decisions.
Promote Forgiveness and Letting Go: Encourage the OP to consider the benefits of forgiveness, not for the bully’s sake, but for their own peace of mind. Letting go of anger can be liberating.
Respect Their Decision: Ultimately, respect the OP’s decision, whether they choose to leave a review or not. Support them in whatever path they decide to take, as this is their personal journey.

Remember, healing from past trauma takes time, and it’s important to approach this situation with empathy and understanding for both yourself and others involved. Finding a balance between honesty and compassion can lead to a more positive outcome for everyone.